Site Navigation

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
FAQ

Troyer's Country Store, LLC

About Us

Troyer’s Country Store, LLC began with a simple idea: to bring the warmth, simplicity, and honest craftsmanship of Amish tradition to the heart of Milroy, IN. What started as a humble country store has grown into a cherished community destination where quality is never rushed, and hospitality is woven into everything we do. Step inside and you’ll find shelves filled with thoughtfully selected groceries, scratch-made bakery favorites, deli meats and cheeses sliced fresh to order, premium local beef, and the everyday kitchen essentials that keep a home running well.

But Troyer’s is more than a place to shop—it’s a place where traditions are kept alive. Our fresh breads and pastries are made using time-honored recipes passed down through generations. Our meats are sourced from trusted local farms that share our commitment to quality and integrity. And every product, from pantry staples to handcrafted treats, reflects a lifestyle grounded in hard work, family, and simple living.

For us, every customer who walks through the door becomes part of our story. We’re honored to serve Milroy and the surrounding communities with the same values we were built on: authenticity, freshness, and a genuine love for people. At Troyer’s Country Store, every visit is a chance to slow down, savor the moment, and experience the richness of Amish heritage—one delicious bite at a time.

Areas Served

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Troyer’s Country Store, LLC is known for bringing together the very best of Amish-country tradition and local farm freshness. Their specialties shine through every part of the store—starting with their handcrafted bakery items made from scratch each morning, and a deli that serves premium meats, cheeses, and simple homemade meals packed with flavor. They’re equally known for their vibrant produce section, offering seasonal fruits and vegetables that are hand-selected for quality, along with locally raised beef trusted for its freshness and exceptional taste. Whether you stop in for wholesome groceries, a warm loaf of bread, or locally sourced goods you can feel good about serving your family, Troyer’s is proud to offer the kind of honest, down-to-earth specialties that keep customers coming back generation after generation.

Our Services include:

Amish Country Store & Grocery Market: Troyer’s Country Store brings the heart of Amish country to the community with a welcoming, old-fashioned shopping experience rooted in quality and tradition. Inside, customers will find a full selection of everyday grocery essentials along with specialty products you’d expect from a true country market—bulk foods, pantry staples, jams, spices, and locally sourced goods. Every aisle reflects Troyer’s commitment to simple living, honest value, and wholesome ingredients.
Fresh Produce & Local Beef: From farm-fresh vegetables and seasonal fruits to locally raised beef, Troyer’s offers customers the kind of freshness you can taste. Their produce is hand-selected for quality, while their beef comes straight from trusted local farms, ensuring exceptional flavor and transparency from pasture to table. Whether you're planning a weeknight dinner or stocking up for the season, Troyer’s provides natural, farm-to-market goodness you can trust.
Homemade Bakery & Deli: The warm aroma of fresh-baked goods sets the tone the moment customers walk through the door. Troyer’s homemade bakery serves up daily delights such as breads, cookies, pies, and pastries—all made from scratch with time-honored recipes. Their deli completes the experience with premium meats and cheeses sliced to order, handcrafted sandwiches, and ready-to-enjoy treats perfect for lunch on the go or family gatherings. It’s comfort, quality, and homemade flavor all in one place.

Our Brands include:

Walnut Creek Cheese
Walnut Creek Foods
Kalmbach Feeds
Tribute

Our Products include:

Groceries
Kitchen Supplies
Local Beef
Homemade Pies
Homemade Cinnamon Rolls
Homemade Cookies
Homemade Bread
White & Wheat Bread
Jalapeño Cheese Bread
Cheese Bread
Apple Cinnamon Bread
Sourdough Bread
Onion Dough Bread
Sweet Breads
Banana Bread
Pumpkin Bread
Fresh Produce: tomatoes, peaches, watermelon, cantaloupe, cucumbers, zucchini & more
Horse Feed
Chicken Feed
Goat Feed
Dog Food
Cat Food

Testimonials

On 1/16/2026 Sally Colestock had this to say:
My favorite store!!! Keeps getting busier all the time! But worth it!

On 1/14/2026 Sheryl Vise had this to say:
We love Troyer's Country Store. Great prices and great food. I recommend getting their sandwich special!

On 1/4/2026 Brian Nicholson had this to say:
It's an Amish grocery. The cheese is great and best value in three states.

On 12/30/2025 Jeff Kissel had this to say:
This place is awesome , always spotless and the prices are great. Large selection of cheeses and lunch meat.

On 12/29/2025 Mikhael Hayes had this to say:
Great goods

Contact Us

Troyer's Country Store, LLC
10599 S SR 3 Milroy, IN 46156
Phone: (765) 629-2604
Email: troyers@starlightprint.com

Located 3 miles south of Milroy

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

American Express, Apple Pay, Personal Checks, Debit Cards, Discover, MasterCard, Visa

Our Hours

Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.

Monday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday: 8:00 AM - 4:00 PM

FAQ

Are there any specials or discounts available?

We have weekly specials on meats and cheeses. You can find our ads in the Rushville Recorder.

Do you carry locally made products?

We happily carry a wide range of products many of which are sourced locally, including milk, ice cream, and more.

Do you sell fresh produce?

We sell fresh produce late Spring - early Fall, subject to availability.